The Pro’s and Cons of Various Residential Floor Coverings

Rick Magliano

The type of floor you have can affect how warm or cold you feel, your overall health, and even your ability to think on your feet. What’s more, owners can instantly change the mood in certain rooms of their homes with different flooring. Here’s a rundown of the most popular residential floor tiles and the best surface protection products to protect them during construction and remodeling.

1. Bamboo: Key feature: Made from the world’s fastest-growing tree.

Pro: Durable; ideal for condos. “Green” material. Has antimicrobial properties. Generally good for home owners with allergies to man-made materials. Available in planks, strips, and tiles.

Con: Cannot be re-finished. Everything from tiny dust particles to high-heeled shoes can damage the surface.

Upkeep: Sweep regularly with soft broom. Entryway rugs can keep dust at bay. Protective pads on furniture limit dents. Clean up spills immediately to prevent stains. Install window shades to limit sun damage.

Surface protection: Protection made from breathable, natural textiles such as Surface Pro.

2. Linoleum: Key feature: Most popular is Marmoleum, a marbled pattern.

Pro: Naturally repels dust and dirt, ideal for home owners with respiratory disorders; durable, long-lasting, and low maintenance. Sheet goods, not tiles, are recommended.

Con: Difficult to install. Has to be heat-welded using equipment not readily available. Pricier than vinyl.

Upkeep: Wax once or twice for a superficial surface. Linseed oil in the linoleum oxidizes when installed, and the floor becomes more durable and lustrous. Wash with mildly soapy water.

Surface protection: Various surface protection products will work including floor protection films, textiles and paper based products such as Ram Board.

3. Cork: Key feature: Renewable, eco-friendly choice.

Pro: This durable flooring has become trendy for residences. Glue-down cork tiles are ideal since they maximize this flooring’s ability to reduce sound and heat loss and retain softness. Naturally keeps mold and insects away; great for home owners with allergies or arthritis. Cost comparable to bamboo.

Con: Does not conduct heat well, and could expand in radiant heating.

Upkeep: Dust mop regularly.

Surface protection: Avoid floor films and choose textile based products such as Surface Liner Pro that will gently adhere to the cork and not leave a mark.

4. Wood: Key feature: Great dance floor.

Pro: Easier on your back than tile or stone. 3/4″ allows for multiple refinishes. How a tree is cut determines the look of the grain.

Con: Not good for radiant heating systems. Maple is hard to stain; white oak is the most versatile. Cherry and walnut are among most popular. Elm, while hardy and long-lasting, is rare. Wider planks, which require fewer nails, are more susceptible to humidity.

Upkeep: Area rugs limit gouges and scratches. Buff before reapplying coats of polyurethane. Dust mop regularly.

Surface protection: Choose padded floor protections if the budget allows. Glue down floors must be breathable so Surface Liner Vapor or Surface Pro are recommended for padded protection or Ram Board for non-padded. Non glue-down wood floors can be protected by leak resistant floor protection such as Clean & Safe.

5. Carpet: Key feature: Classic, comfortable.

Pro: Wool variety is great for homes and feels wonderful underfoot. It also absorbs sounds, is easy to clean, and generally durable, as long as you buy quality good carpet and yarns.

Con: Avoid nylon varieties, which usually have a latex backing, which crumbles easily. Choice may not be environmentally friendly. Natural trap for dander, dirt, and dust particles. Tends to retain moisture, breeding ground for mold.

Upkeep: Steam-clean annually. Vacuum twice a week.

Surface protection: Short term adhesive carpet film is available for up to 45 days.

6. Ceramic Tiles: Key feature: Long-lasting.

Pro: Low-maintenance; ceramic holds up well in high-traffic areas. Great investment, lots of design options available. Most common, effective flooring for radiant heat systems.

Con: Not an ideal surface for home owners with arthritis. Hard to install. Can crack and chip easily. Sometimes feels cool to the touch.

Upkeep: While expensive, professional installation is highly recommended. Use mild cleanser to clean grout to retain mold-resistant sealant.

Surface protection: Various surface protection products will work including floor protection films, textiles and paper based products such as Ram Board.

7. Decorative Concrete: Key feature: Trendy, popular in condos.

Pro: Inexpensive, easy maintenance. Absorbs warmth of the sun in winter, reducing the need for heating, and keeps interiors cool in summer. Doesn’t harbor dust mites; ideal for home owners with allergies or asthma. Long-lasting; never needs to be replaced.

Con: Hard on joints. Magnifies sound. Installation requires professional expertise, which can be costly.

Upkeep: Re-seal every two years. Clean with vinegar and water mix or a mild floor cleaner.

Surface protection: New concrete protection products include EZ Cover or Tuf-guard which provide impact protection and allow the concrete to cure.

8. Natural Stone: Key feature: Gorgeous.

Pro: Encompasses granite, marble, travertine, limestone, soapstone, and slate. Lasts for centuries. Great value and eco-friendly too. Stain-resistant. Expensive installation. Options include matte, shiny, and textured finishes.

Con: Tough on your joints. May need substantial subfloor. Marble absorbs dirt; slate and limestone collect it. Feels cool underfoot, which can make it an excellent choice in hot climates, but less so in cold weather.

Upkeep: Needs stain-resistant sealer. Avoid chlorine on marble.

Surface protection: Various surface protection products will work including floor protection films, textiles and paper based products such as Ram Board. Protects grout from stains as well.

9. Leather: Key feature: Luxurious look.

Pro: A home owner can install leather tiles; they go in just like linoleum. Smells wonderful, feels great, gains patina with age and wear. Great for sound insulation; doesn’t conduct heat or cold.

Con: Don’t install in a high foot traffic spot; they’re best in extremely dry rooms such as bedrooms, dens, libraries, and even rec rooms with lots of sunlight. Expensive.

Upkeep: Some leather tiles are treated with wax and a water-resistant solution. However, any mistake is costly, so a professional may be ultimately cheaper.

Surface protection: Choose padded textile floor protection such as Surface Pro or Surface Liner vapor to allow the leather to breathe.

Leave a Reply

Next Post

Renewable Energy Options For The Home - Part 1 - Biomass-Wood Pellet - Hydropower- Wind Power

The use of energy in our homes is inescapable, providing heating and electricity within the home. Traditionally, we have been reliant on fossil fuels such as coal, gas and oil to provide for our energy needs. Fossil fuels by nature are a finite resource and will eventually run-out. In addition […]
Renewable Energy Options For The Home – Part 1 – Biomass-Wood Pellet – Hydropower- Wind Power

You May Like